Skip to main content

New York Style Pepperoni Pizza~ Baking Partners Challenge# 10

New York Style Pepperoni Pizza

 Baking Partners challenge# 10 is New York Style Pizza. Baking partners is the brain child of  Swathi of Zesty South Indian Kitchen. It is a wonderful group of enthusiastic blogger who try something new in baking every month. Making Pizza dough was quiet challenging for me.  This recipe called for the thin crusted hand tossed pizza. I do not make pizza often at home. My kid loves pepperoni pizza and I make the quick version using  naan as crust. It took a while for me to practice, but I am glad I finally made a pizza from the scratch. This recipe was suggested by Archana of Tangy Minds. Thanks Archana and Swathi for this challenge.

Recipe suggested by Archana
Recipe adapted from SeriousEats.(


For the crust
Bread flour- 4 1/2 cup 22 1/2 ounces
Sugar- 2 1/2 tbs
Salt- 1 tsp
Instant Yeast - 2tsp
Extra virgin olive oil- 3 tbs
Luke warm water- 15 oz.

For the sauce
Diced tomatoes/peeled tomatoes- 28 oz. (1 can)
Extra virgin olive oil- 1 tbs
Butter- 1 tbs
Garlic 2 cloves
Dried oregano- 1 tsp
Red pepper flakes- a pinch
Salt-to taste
Basil- a few
Onion- 1 medium
Sugar- 1 tsp

Pepperoni- as needed
Mozzarella cheese- 1 cup

To make the dough for the crust
Combine flour, sugar, salt, and yeast in bowl and mix well. In a mixture add the flour, olive oil and water and start to combine and continue till it forms into a ball ( or if with the hand mix and knead till all the flour comes together)Transfer into a floured surface and knead till it is smooth for about three to four minutes. The dough will not be sticky and will be perfectly smooth. Divide into three equal parts. Take each ball separately, roll and smooth-en the top while pinching the ends and twisting. Finally flatten with your palm. Gently brush oil on top of the dough and let it rest for half an hour. After that transfer quart-sized deli container or in a zipper-lock freezer bag. Place in refrigerator and allow to rise at least one day. This dough can be rested like this for up to 5 days.

To make the sauce
Pulse the tomatoes and their juice in food processor /mixie until pureed. It should not be completely smooth. Set tomatoes aside.Combine butter and oil in medium saucepan and heat over medium-low heat until butter is melted. Add garlic pepper flakes and fry until fragrant. Add  basil sprigs, onion chopped  and sugar and stir for two minutes till onion changes color Add the tomatoes, oregano, salt  and bring to a simmer, reduce heat to lowest setting (bubbles should barely be breaking the surface), and cook, stirring occasionally, until reduced by 1/2, about 1 hour.  Allow to cool and refrigate.

Bring the dough to room temperature( leave on the counter for at least two hours). Shape into balls by gathering dough towards bottom and pinching shut. Flour well and place each one in a separate medium mixing bowl. Cover tightly with plastic wrap and allow to rise at warm room temperature until roughly doubled in volume. Place Pizza stone in the oven and preheat oven to 400°F. Turn single dough ball out onto lightly flour surface. Gently press out dough into rough 8-inch circle, leaving outer 1-inch higher than the rest. Gently stretch dough by draping on your left hand and using the knuckles of the right  gently stretch the dough. Continue this draping and stretching and rotating the dough in a clock wise direction till you have a thin uniform dough about 10 to 12-inch circle about 1/4-inch thick. Transfer to pizza peeler or a parchment paper. Spread  sauce evenly over surface of crust, leaving 1/2 to 1-inch border along edge. Add toppings of your choice. Here I used cheese and then arranged pepperoni. Bake until cheese is melts and crust is golden brown. Let it rest for a few minutes, slice and serve.


 Try this,
Hope you will all enjoy!


  1. Perfectly done pepperoni pizza, Suja! My daughters will love this!

  2. The color of the pizza is so attractive and delicious...

  3. Thats a good looking pizza Suja, u have nailed it :)

  4. Though I don't eat pepperoni, the pizza looks perfect..

  5. looks too tempting suja!! I love it!!

  6. NY pizza are always good. u have made it perfect dear.

  7. Wow lovely pizza... What happened to ur previous prawn vermicelli post... I tried to comment on it but could not

  8. Colourfull pizza.loved the topping.

  9. The perfected pepperoni pie. Great job!

  10. Inviting pizza dear...looks like u r expert in making pizza :)

  11. Perfectly made pizza...looks wonderful

  12. Very detailed post and lovely pizza...

  13. This looks so authentic...straight out from a pizzeria!!

  14. This looks so authentic, straight out from a pizzeria!!

  15. your pizza looks brilliant ! as amrita commented... looks like you got it from a pizzeria.

  16. Adipoli pizza Suja you did very well.

  17. looks sooo inviting n tempting....

  18. that looks so professional.. :)

  19. Luv the look yaar! I agree with sojo, pizza looks completely professional

  20. Amazingggggggggggggggggggggggggg and wow so thin and thank u so much :) IT was amazed to see it and loved it.Visit my space when u r free dear.

  21. Hey Suja, for some reason, I can comment only on your latest post, I saw your strawberry pudding, but I cannot comment on it, I don't know why..

  22. Double like for the pepproni topped pizza. Love the clicks too.

  23. Pizza looks great, but loved shrimp rice noodle oh my! Wasn't able to comment there, it just looks wonderful!

  24. Pizza looks simple and fabulous...pepperoni luks crown of the pizza

  25. looks perfect...simply mouthwatering

  26. I have never attempted to completely home make a pizza before but there is a first time for everything. Thank you so much for giving ample details for making the pizza. I have never had New York style pizza so I am going to hope for the best.

    Julia @Online PhD Resources


Post a Comment

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...

Popular posts from this blog

Stuffed Pomfret With Green Masala- A Guest Post at Cooking-Varieties

I am extremely delighted and honored to be a guest at Wan's Cooking Varieties. When she asked me for a guest post I was so excited.She is one of my favorite foodie friends .She is very warm and friendly person and I love her blog. There is always a healthy edge in her cooking which is really inspiring.It has beautiful write-ups about food, health benefits and healthy eating habits.She has always shown genuine appreciation for other culture and culinary traditions. I am honored to be in your esteemed space.

Thanks Wan for this opportunity.

Recipe is  pomfret stuffed with a green masala and prawns filling...Hop over to Wan's place for the recipe..

Wan sent me this card with beautiful bouquet of roses,this made my day  :)
so sweet of you Wan..really appreciate this:)

Once again thanks Wan for this opportunity
Hope you will all enjoy..
Have a great day!


Kerala Chicken Roast

Spicy Kerala Chicken Roast is another nadan recipe and a family favorite. It is a dry version and is great accompaniment with rice, chapathi or fried rice.The chicken in this recipe is usually deep fried or shallow fried, (some times whole stuffed chicken ) and then coated with the masala. Here I have shallow fried the chicken.It  tasted delicious with fried rice. Give this recipe a try...

1)Chicken - 1 lb
 Chilly powder -1 1/2
Turmeric powder-1/2 tsp
Powdered Garam masala-
(Two tsp of fennel powder, 5-6 cloves,2 inch stick
cinnamon, a small piece of nutmeg, 2 cardamon )
Vinegar- 1 1/2 tsp
Salt to taste

For the Masala
Thinly sliced Onion- 2 medium
Thinly sliced ginger- 3-4 tsp
Thinly sliced garlic- 3-4 tsp
Chopped green chilly- 2
( I used 2 Jalapeno pepper instead of green chilly)
Coriander powder- 3/4 tsp
Chilly powder- 1/2 tsp(optional)
Turmeric powder- a pinch
Meat  Masala- 1 tsp
Curry leaves
Pepper powder- 1/2 tsp

Dry roast the ingredients under garam masala …

Nadan Mutton Curry

Nadan Mutton curry
If you wish for some spicy non vegetarian recipes here is one to relish on...nadan mutton curry made with authentic Kerala spices. What makes this dish flavorful and inviting is the flavor of fresh ground masala, coconut oil and the fresh taste of curry leaves.In this recipe I have also added  mint. I love adding fried mint in my home made mutton curry just like my mom( but it is optional). It is spicy and delicious and is a great combo with rice, ghee rice or appam


Mutton - 1 kg
Shallots sliced- 2 cups
Onion- 1 small
Coconut slices- a few
Green chilly-5-6
Ginger and garlic minced- 4-5 tsp
Chilly powder- 1 1/2 tsp
Coriander powder- 3 tsp
Turmeric powder- 1/2 tsp
Garam Masala- 1 1/3 tsp
Fennel powder- 1/2 tsp
pepper powder- 1/2 tsp
clove - 2
cinnamon stick- 1 small
Curry leaves- 1 spring
Mint leaves-a few
salt to taste

Cut mutton pieces into small cubes and marinate with pepper powder,salt, turmeric powder, fennel powder and a few curry leaves and set aside for h…

Nadan Vaala Meen Curry/BeltFish Curry

Nadan Vaala Meen Curry
This is a nadan style fish curry. It is my grandmothers recipe. When ever she gets vaala meen/ribbon fish/belt fish she makes a similar curry . This is a varutharacha meen curry/roasted coconut gravy. You can also make it without roasting the masala. But the roasting gives a distinct aroma and enhances the taste of the curry. You can add regular tamarind as souring agent or fish tamarind/kudampuli. Try this you will surely love it.

Ingredients Vaala meen- 1 kg
Pearl onion- 2 cup (roughly chopped)
Dry Kashmiri red chilly-12-15
Coconut grated- 1 cup
Thondan mulaku/banana peppers-2
Ginger- 1/2 inch thick
Muringakka/drumstick- 10-12 pieces
Kudampuli/Malabar Tamarind- 3 pieces
(or tamarind lemon sized ball)
Turmeric powder-a pinch
Mustard- 1/2 tsp
Fenugreek seeds- 1/3 tsp
Curry leaves- 1 spring
oil and salt to taste

Clean the fish, sprinkle salt on a broad and a rub the fish  with salt. Rinse and cut into small pieces. Soak kudam puli/ Malabar tamarind in 1/2 cup wa…

Spicy Stuffed Eggplant

Spicy Stuffed Eggplant
Today's recipe is meat stuffed spicy eggplant inspired from Lebanese and Turkish Cuisine. Recently I am trying  lot of stuffed dishes with chicken,squid and fish. This stuffed eggplant is now one of my top favorites. Eggplant is a versatile veggie and cooked in the right way, you can create innumerable recipes with it.Fried or baked eggplant is tender and tasty and goes well with rice. If you are not a great fan of eggplant/aubergine, try this stuffed version.It is insanely good and I am sure will change the way you think about this humble veggie.

Stuffed eggplant is great as a main course dish. You can serve it with rice,bread or with fresh salad and you have a satisfying dinner. It is also perfect when you have guests as it is filling and makes a pretty presentation.In Turkish and Mediterranean region Karniyarik is an imperial dish fit for a King or chieftain.You can use lentils and mushroom for a vegetarian version.There is also a Thai version of stuffed…

Chemeen Masala Varattiyathu/ Pan roasted Prawns

Chemeen Varattiyathu is a popular sea food delicacy of Kerala. It is not fried prawns but gravy with is almost semi-dry. It is a great side dish for rice. It has the enticing flavors of garam masala and coconut oil and curry leaves. It is spicy, peppery and a bit tangy due to the use of   Kukum or kudampuli. You can instead add tomatoes or lemon juice. You can also add coconut pieces in the recipes and it gives a crunchy bites along with the prawns.

Prawns- 1 lb
Shallots chopped- 1 cup
Ginger and garlic paste- 2 tsp
Chilly powder - 1 1/2 tsp
Pepper powder-1/2 tsp
Coriander powder- 2 tsp
Turmeric powder- 1/3 tsp
Garam masala- 3/4 tsp
fenugreek powder- 1/3 tsp
Kukum- 2-3 pieces 
Fennel powder- 1/2 tsp (optional)
curry leaves
Coconut pieces( Optional)
Coconut oil

Clean and marinate prawns with salt, turmeric, pepper and fennel powder and keep it aside for fifteen minutes.
In a pan heat oil and saute shallots till lightly golden brown. Add in ginger garlic paste, curry leaves and saute for …

Kerala Fish Curry ( Mulaku Curry)

Kerala's Red Fish Curry or the Mulaku Charu is hot and spicy fish curry. Its rich color is from Kashmiri chilly powder which is less spicy when compared to regular chilly powder.

Fish curry and rice or fish curry and kappa pukku is the absolute comfort food for every malayali. The state is blessed  with long coast line, backwaters and lake and Keralites are great fish eaters. Red fish curry tastes awesome and you can find this type of fish curry everywhere-in  homes, restaurants,toddy shops or boat houses for tourists. Even though this curry is staple for the malayalis, you will still find a lot of regional variation to this recipe. Each region and each home has its own adaption of fish curry.

The tamarind used in this recipe is Kudampuli/ Gambooge/Malabar tamarind. You can find this in abundance in Central and North Kerala. This souring agent has lots of medicinal value and helps aid digestion.
Malayalis love adding coconut to every dish, but this curry is an exception. But it…